CLAIM-SURFACE MAP — TWO FILLED FICTIONAL EXAMPLES Status: local companion asset; not publication or destination evidence Author: Alfred Purpose ------- These two explicitly fictional records exercise the copyable claim-surface-map worksheet. They show why a correction decision needs a supported basis, forward and backward traces, exact-delivery inspection, and separate local, promotion, and destination states. All identifiers, values, media, revisions, and findings below are synthetic. The examples describe no real person, customer, account, correction, upload, publication, audience, metric, dispute, accessibility result, or platform outcome. They do not establish universal accuracy, legal compliance, destination refresh, cache eviction, publication, or authority to upload, publish, promote, or contact. Evidence states used -------------------- CORRECT_WITHIN_RECORDED_SCOPE Inspected surface communicates the supported correction. OLD_CLAIM_PRESENT Superseded meaning remains on a required surface. CONTRADICTORY Inspected surfaces communicate incompatible meanings. BLOCKED Required basis, identity, surface, tool, or authority is absent. NOT_TESTED Declared check was not performed. UNCERTAIN Inspection cannot support a reliable decision. SUPERSEDED Evidence belongs to an older claim or candidate. One required OLD_CLAIM_PRESENT, CONTRADICTORY, BLOCKED, NOT_TESTED, or UNCERTAIN state prevents approval. States are not scores and are never averaged. ======================================================================== EXAMPLE 1 — CORRECT PICTURE AND CAPTIONS, STALE NARRATION ======================================================================== Scenario boundary ----------------- A fictional twelve-second geometric animation reports the duration of one synthetic local test. Draft wording says five seconds. The admitted synthetic timing record supports eight seconds. The script, visible counter, and captions are corrected, but a flattened narration mix from the earlier revision remains in the delivery. This is a deliberately failing fixture. It proves no behavior of an editor, encoder, captioner, host, or destination. A. CORRECTION AND CANDIDATE ENVELOPE ------------------------------------ correction_id: FICTIONAL-CORR-A01 review_started_at: SYNTHETIC-TIME-A01 review_completed_at: SYNTHETIC-TIME-A02 reviewer_role: fictional release reviewer publication_state: NOT_PUBLIC old_claim_exact_wording: The fictional test completed in five seconds. old_claim_semantic_identity: one synthetic test duration equals five seconds corrected_claim_exact_wording: The fictional test completed in eight seconds. corrected_claim_semantic_identity: one synthetic test duration equals eight seconds reason_for_correction: fictional source transcription error correction_scope: one synthetic demonstration only claims_or_conclusions_explicitly_out_of_scope: speed, reliability, benchmarks, and general performance known_paraphrases_of_old_meaning: completed in 5 s; took about five; counter ending at 5 known_numeric_unit_visual_or_spoken_variants: 5; 5.0; five seconds; approximately five source_evidence_revision: SYNTHETIC-TIMING-A08 source_evidence_location_or_immutable_label: admitted fictional timing table row TEST-A source_scope_and_limitations: one generated example; not a benchmark or real measurement script_or_article_revision: SCRIPT-A03 picture_revision: PICTURE-A04 sound_or_mix_revision: MIX-A02 intended_sound_revision: MIX-A03 caption_revision: CAPTION-A04 discovery_copy_revision: DISCOVERY-A02 promotion_copy_revision: PROMOTION-A01 candidate_manifest_revision: MANIFEST-A05 delivery_member_byte_identities: VIDEO-A05; CAPTION-A04; POSTER-A02 intended_destination_class: NONE — local method fixture only destination_rendition_identity: NOT_OBSERVED identity_gate_state: CORRECT_WITHIN_RECORDED_SCOPE identity_gate_evidence: old meaning, corrected meaning, basis, scope, variants, and exact fictional revisions recorded identity_gate_notes: sound identity is intentionally stale relative to the intended revision B. BASIS, PROPAGATION, AND CROSS-SURFACE DECISIONS -------------------------------------------------- Basis decision source_supports_corrected_claim: YES source_scope_matches_claim_scope: YES source_limitations_preserved: YES basis_state: CORRECT_WITHIN_RECORDED_SCOPE basis_evidence: SYNTHETIC-TIMING-A08 records eight seconds for synthetic TEST-A basis_notes: the record supports no comparison or generalized speed claim Propagation decision every_known_dependent_surface_mapped: YES every_old_meaning_path_terminated: NO every_final_claim_bearing_member_has_current_basis: NO propagation_state: OLD_CLAIM_PRESENT propagation_evidence: exact delivery MIX-A02 audibly says five seconds propagation_notes: editable script state cannot substitute for the flattened mix Cross-surface decision picture_sound_timed_text_agree_in_meaning: NO discovery_and_promotion_preserve_scope: YES visual_conclusions_match_corrected_basis: YES intentional_omissions_have_accuracy_reasons: YES cross_surface_state: CONTRADICTORY cross_surface_evidence: picture and captions say eight while sound says five cross_surface_notes: required channels disagree on the only numeric claim decision_gate_state: CONTRADICTORY decision_gate_evidence: basis passes independently; propagation and cross-surface lanes fail decision_gate_notes: agreement cannot be inferred from two correct surfaces C. CLAIM-SURFACE INVENTORY -------------------------- A-SOURCE-01 surface_class: SOURCE surface_role: admitted synthetic timing basis relative_path_or_immutable_label: SYNTHETIC-TIMING-A08 row TEST-A byte_identity_or_revision: SYNTHETIC-TIMING-A08 claim_relationship: DIRECT required_for_release: YES required_inspection_method: source-row and scope review inspection_state: CORRECT_WITHIN_RECORDED_SCOPE evidence: row records eight seconds and labels the example synthetic A-SOURCE-02 surface_class: SOURCE surface_role: narration and picture script relative_path_or_immutable_label: SCRIPT-A03 byte_identity_or_revision: SCRIPT-A03 claim_relationship: DIRECT required_for_release: YES required_inspection_method: complete text review inspection_state: CORRECT_WITHIN_RECORDED_SCOPE evidence: spoken line and counter instruction both specify eight seconds A-PICTURE-01 surface_class: PICTURE surface_role: rendered counter and final title card relative_path_or_immutable_label: PICTURE-A04 inside VIDEO-A05 byte_identity_or_revision: VIDEO-A05 claim_relationship: VISUAL_DERIVATION required_for_release: YES required_inspection_method: complete normal-speed playback plus final-frame pause inspection_state: CORRECT_WITHIN_RECORDED_SCOPE evidence: counter ends at 8 and title card reads eight seconds A-SOUND-01 surface_class: SOUND surface_role: flattened narration mix relative_path_or_immutable_label: MIX-A02 inside VIDEO-A05 byte_identity_or_revision: VIDEO-A05 audio track claim_relationship: DIRECT required_for_release: YES required_inspection_method: complete mix listening inspection_state: OLD_CLAIM_PRESENT evidence: narration audibly says five seconds at fictional interval 00:00:06–00:00:08 A-TEXT-01 surface_class: TIMED_TEXT surface_role: sidecar captions relative_path_or_immutable_label: CAPTION-A04 byte_identity_or_revision: CAPTION-A04 claim_relationship: DIRECT required_for_release: YES required_inspection_method: full caption read and synchronized playback inspection_state: CORRECT_WITHIN_RECORDED_SCOPE evidence: cue at fictional interval 00:00:06–00:00:08 says eight seconds A-DISCOVERY-01 surface_class: DISCOVERY surface_role: fictional title, description, excerpt, poster alt text relative_path_or_immutable_label: DISCOVERY-A02 byte_identity_or_revision: DISCOVERY-A02 claim_relationship: NOT_APPLICABLE not_applicable_reason: copy describes a synthetic timing correction without stating a duration required_for_release: YES required_inspection_method: complete text and visual review inspection_state: CORRECT_WITHIN_RECORDED_SCOPE evidence: no duration or implied speed comparison appears A-PACKAGE-01 surface_class: PACKAGE surface_role: manifest and admitted members relative_path_or_immutable_label: MANIFEST-A05 byte_identity_or_revision: MANIFEST-A05 claim_relationship: DEPENDENT_CONCLUSION required_for_release: YES required_inspection_method: manifest closure and member identity comparison inspection_state: OLD_CLAIM_PRESENT evidence: manifest admits VIDEO-A05, whose audio track contains MIX-A02 A-PROMOTION-01 surface_class: PROMOTION surface_role: prepared first-party copy relative_path_or_immutable_label: PROMOTION-A01 byte_identity_or_revision: PROMOTION-A01 claim_relationship: NOT_APPLICABLE not_applicable_reason: prepared copy names the method but states no duration required_for_release: NO required_inspection_method: complete text review inspection_state: CORRECT_WITHIN_RECORDED_SCOPE evidence: copy contains no old claim, corrected claim, metric, or publication claim A-DESTINATION-01 surface_class: DESTINATION surface_role: provider rendition or generated text relative_path_or_immutable_label: NONE byte_identity_or_revision: NOT_OBSERVED claim_relationship: DIRECT required_for_release: NO required_inspection_method: authorized post-transfer logged-out review inspection_state: NOT_TESTED evidence: no transfer or publication occurred inventory_gate_state: CORRECT_WITHIN_RECORDED_SCOPE inventory_gate_evidence: eight classes considered; seven applicable local surfaces recorded; destination remains separate inventory_gate_notes: complete inventory does not convert failing members into a pass D. FORWARD TRACE FROM THE OLD MEANING ------------------------------------- A-PATH-01 from_claim_or_surface_identity: old semantic identity — five-second duration copy_or_transformation: draft wording copied into SCRIPT-A01 next_surface_id: superseded SCRIPT-A01 old_meaning_possible: YES inspection_state: SUPERSEDED evidence: SCRIPT-A01 preserved as historical fictional revision next_path_or_terminal_surface: A-PATH-02 and A-PATH-03 A-PATH-02 from_claim_or_surface_identity: superseded SCRIPT-A01 spoken line copy_or_transformation: fictional narration recording and flattening next_surface_id: A-SOUND-01 old_meaning_possible: YES inspection_state: OLD_CLAIM_PRESENT evidence: MIX-A02 in exact delivery audibly preserves five seconds next_path_or_terminal_surface: terminal failing surface A-PATH-03 from_claim_or_surface_identity: superseded SCRIPT-A01 picture and caption instructions copy_or_transformation: corrected before PICTURE-A04 and CAPTION-A04 generation next_surface_id: A-PICTURE-01 and A-TEXT-01 old_meaning_possible: NO within inspected scope inspection_state: CORRECT_WITHIN_RECORDED_SCOPE evidence: complete picture and caption review show eight seconds next_path_or_terminal_surface: verified corrected terminals forward_trace_state: OLD_CLAIM_PRESENT forward_trace_evidence: old meaning terminates at required sound surface A-SOUND-01 forward_trace_notes: one surviving path prevents closure E. BACKWARD TRACE FROM FINAL CLAIM-BEARING MEMBERS -------------------------------------------------- VIDEO-A05 picture counter immediate_source_identity: SCRIPT-A03 and PICTURE-A04 ultimate_basis_revision: SYNTHETIC-TIMING-A08 communicated_meaning: synthetic duration equals eight seconds supports_corrected_meaning: YES old_meaning_could_survive: NO within inspected picture lineage_state: CORRECT_WITHIN_RECORDED_SCOPE VIDEO-A05 narration immediate_source_identity: MIX-A02 derived from superseded SCRIPT-A01 ultimate_basis_revision: superseded fictional transcription communicated_meaning: synthetic duration equals five seconds supports_corrected_meaning: NO old_meaning_could_survive: YES lineage_state: OLD_CLAIM_PRESENT CAPTION-A04 cue immediate_source_identity: SCRIPT-A03 ultimate_basis_revision: SYNTHETIC-TIMING-A08 communicated_meaning: synthetic duration equals eight seconds supports_corrected_meaning: YES old_meaning_could_survive: NO within inspected captions lineage_state: CORRECT_WITHIN_RECORDED_SCOPE backward_trace_state: OLD_CLAIM_PRESENT backward_trace_evidence: final delivery sound traces to superseded SCRIPT-A01 backward_trace_notes: a current filename would not repair stale lineage F. SEARCH, MEANING, AND PERCEPTUAL INSPECTION --------------------------------------------- exact_text_search: finding: no exact draft sentence in current editable text or sidecar captions state: CORRECT_WITHIN_RECORDED_SCOPE limitation: cannot inspect flattened speech or visual equivalents numeric_and_unit_search: finding: current source and captions contain eight; no text token for five state: CORRECT_WITHIN_RECORDED_SCOPE limitation: cannot establish audible meaning structural_inspection: finding: VIDEO-A05 audio track points to MIX-A02, not intended MIX-A03 state: OLD_CLAIM_PRESENT visual_review: finding: complete picture and boundaries communicate eight seconds state: CORRECT_WITHIN_RECORDED_SCOPE listening_review: finding: complete mix says five seconds once state: OLD_CLAIM_PRESENT cross_surface_review: finding: picture and captions contradict narration state: CONTRADICTORY lineage_review: finding: sound derives from superseded script while picture and captions derive from current basis state: OLD_CLAIM_PRESENT metadata_review: finding: admitted synthetic metadata contains no duration state: CORRECT_WITHIN_RECORDED_SCOPE inspection_matrix_state: CONTRADICTORY inspection_matrix_evidence: listening and lineage reveal a failure missed by text search inspection_matrix_notes: exact-string cleanliness is not semantic closure G. EXACT DELIVERY AND PACKAGE REVIEW ------------------------------------ delivery_package_revision: PACKAGE-A05 manifest_revision: MANIFEST-A05 package_members_observed: VIDEO-A05; CAPTION-A04; POSTER-A02 package_matches_manifest: YES complete_picture_playback: YES complete_sound_playback: YES normal_speed_playback: YES opening_boundary_reviewed: YES final_boundary_reviewed: YES cuts_and_dense_transitions_replayed: YES burned_in_text_and_charts_reviewed: YES captions_and_timed_text_reviewed: YES title_description_excerpt_reviewed: YES thumbnail_preview_and_alt_text_reviewed: YES container_and_file_metadata_reviewed: YES superseded_outputs_excluded: NO delivery_finding: narration at fictional interval 00:00:06–00:00:08 says five seconds state: OLD_CLAIM_PRESENT required_repair: rebuild narration as MIX-A03, create new delivery and manifest identities, then repeat affected review delivery_gate_state: OLD_CLAIM_PRESENT delivery_gate_evidence: exact admitted video contains stale narration H. CHANGE AND INVALIDATION MAP ------------------------------ change_id: FICTIONAL-CHANGE-A06 changed_identity: MIX-A02 to proposed MIX-A03 change_summary: replace stale five-second narration with supported eight-second narration dependent_claims_or_conclusions: duration statement and cross-channel consistency historical_evidence_marked: SUPERSEDED reopened_sound_surfaces: narration edit and complete mix reopened_timed_text_surfaces: synchronized cue meaning and timing reopened_package_surfaces: VIDEO byte identity and MANIFEST identity reopened_delivery_surfaces: complete sound, dense transitions, container metadata, and final package closure unaffected_candidate_evidence: source basis and picture only if their exact identities and dependencies remain unchanged recheck_state: NOT_TESTED evidence: repair is proposed, not performed in this fictional record I. TERMINAL DECISION -------------------- selected_decision: HOLD_OLD_CLAIM_PRESENT correction_id: FICTIONAL-CORR-A01 basis_state: CORRECT_WITHIN_RECORDED_SCOPE propagation_state: OLD_CLAIM_PRESENT cross_surface_state: CONTRADICTORY final_review_state: FAIL remaining_unknowns: proposed MIX-A03 and rebuilt delivery were not created or reviewed; destination is NOT_TESTED bounded_statement: The synthetic eight-second basis, picture, and captions passed within recorded scope, but exact delivery sound still says five seconds; release remains held. publication_state: NOT_PUBLIC promotion_state: NOT_POSTED_OR_QUEUED ======================================================================== EXAMPLE 2 — CORRECT LOCAL PACKAGE, STALE PREPARED SUMMARY ======================================================================== Scenario boundary ----------------- A fictional six-panel checklist originally says that four review lanes are enough. The admitted method revision requires six named lanes. The article, picture card, and local package are corrected to six, but a prepared first-party summary still says four. No upload or publication occurs. This fixture tests a release-adjacent text surface. It proves no destination cache, feed, social-preview, accessibility, publication, audience, or platform behavior. A. CORRECTION AND CANDIDATE ENVELOPE ------------------------------------ correction_id: FICTIONAL-CORR-B01 review_started_at: SYNTHETIC-TIME-B01 review_completed_at: SYNTHETIC-TIME-B02 reviewer_role: fictional package reviewer publication_state: NOT_PUBLIC old_claim_exact_wording: Review these four lanes. old_claim_semantic_identity: four lanes are the complete declared review set corrected_claim_exact_wording: Review these six separate lanes. corrected_claim_semantic_identity: the declared method requires six named and separate lanes reason_for_correction: fictional method revision added privacy and accessibility-text lanes correction_scope: one synthetic checklist package and its prepared first-party copy claims_or_conclusions_explicitly_out_of_scope: legal sufficiency, universal completeness, and destination behavior known_paraphrases_of_old_meaning: four checks; all four lanes; 4-part review known_numeric_unit_visual_or_spoken_variants: numeral 4; four columns; four icons source_evidence_revision: METHOD-B06 source_scope_and_limitations: original fictional method definition for this fixture only script_or_article_revision: ARTICLE-B06 picture_revision: CARD-B06 sound_or_mix_revision: NOT_APPLICABLE_WITH_REASON — package has no sound caption_revision: NOT_APPLICABLE_WITH_REASON — package has no timed media discovery_copy_revision: DISCOVERY-B06 promotion_copy_revision: PROMOTION-B04 candidate_manifest_revision: MANIFEST-B06 delivery_member_byte_identities: ARTICLE-B06; CARD-B06; WORKSHEET-B06 intended_destination_class: owned first-party static site, not transferred destination_rendition_identity: NOT_OBSERVED identity_gate_state: CORRECT_WITHIN_RECORDED_SCOPE identity_gate_evidence: exact old and corrected meanings, six-lane basis, package identities, and stale promotion identity recorded B. BASIS, PROPAGATION, AND CROSS-SURFACE DECISIONS -------------------------------------------------- Basis decision source_supports_corrected_claim: YES source_scope_matches_claim_scope: YES source_limitations_preserved: YES basis_state: CORRECT_WITHIN_RECORDED_SCOPE basis_evidence: METHOD-B06 defines rights, attribution, privacy, accuracy, quality, and accessibility-text lanes basis_notes: method does not claim universal or legal completeness Propagation decision every_known_dependent_surface_mapped: YES every_old_meaning_path_terminated: NO every_final_claim_bearing_member_has_current_basis: YES for package; NO for prepared promotion surface propagation_state: OLD_CLAIM_PRESENT propagation_evidence: PROMOTION-B04 says complete four-lane review propagation_notes: not posting stale copy prevents public contradiction but does not make prepared copy current Cross-surface decision picture_sound_timed_text_agree_in_meaning: YES for applicable local package members discovery_and_promotion_preserve_scope: NO visual_conclusions_match_corrected_basis: YES intentional_omissions_have_accuracy_reasons: YES cross_surface_state: CONTRADICTORY cross_surface_evidence: article, card, worksheet, and discovery say six; prepared summary says four cross_surface_notes: promotion is separately held and remains not posted or queued decision_gate_state: CONTRADICTORY decision_gate_evidence: local package can pass while release-adjacent prepared copy fails C. CLAIM-SURFACE INVENTORY -------------------------- B-SOURCE-01 surface_class: SOURCE surface_role: fictional method definition byte_identity_or_revision: METHOD-B06 claim_relationship: DIRECT required_for_release: YES inspection_state: CORRECT_WITHIN_RECORDED_SCOPE evidence: six lanes are individually named and scoped B-PICTURE-01 surface_class: PICTURE surface_role: six-column method card byte_identity_or_revision: CARD-B06 claim_relationship: VISUAL_DERIVATION required_for_release: YES inspection_state: CORRECT_WITHIN_RECORDED_SCOPE evidence: rendered card contains six labeled columns and no four-lane completeness claim B-SOUND-01 surface_class: SOUND surface_role: no sound admitted to this static package byte_identity_or_revision: NOT_APPLICABLE claim_relationship: NOT_APPLICABLE not_applicable_reason: exact manifest contains no audio or timed media required_for_release: NO inspection_state: CORRECT_WITHIN_RECORDED_SCOPE B-TEXT-01 surface_class: TIMED_TEXT surface_role: no timed text admitted byte_identity_or_revision: NOT_APPLICABLE claim_relationship: NOT_APPLICABLE not_applicable_reason: exact manifest contains no timed media required_for_release: NO inspection_state: CORRECT_WITHIN_RECORDED_SCOPE B-DISCOVERY-01 surface_class: DISCOVERY surface_role: title, excerpt, feed summary, preview description, and card alt text byte_identity_or_revision: DISCOVERY-B06 claim_relationship: PARAPHRASE required_for_release: YES inspection_state: CORRECT_WITHIN_RECORDED_SCOPE evidence: every inspected string says six separate lanes or avoids a lane count without implying four B-PACKAGE-01 surface_class: PACKAGE surface_role: article, card, worksheet, and manifest byte_identity_or_revision: MANIFEST-B06 claim_relationship: DIRECT required_for_release: YES inspection_state: CORRECT_WITHIN_RECORDED_SCOPE evidence: exact member review finds six-lane method consistently represented B-PROMOTION-01 surface_class: PROMOTION surface_role: prepared first-party summary byte_identity_or_revision: PROMOTION-B04 claim_relationship: DIRECT required_for_release: NO required_inspection_method: complete text and lifecycle-state review inspection_state: OLD_CLAIM_PRESENT evidence: summary says “complete four-lane review” notes: file remains local, not posted, not queued, and blocked from use B-DESTINATION-01 surface_class: DESTINATION surface_role: hypothetical provider page, feed cache, and generated preview byte_identity_or_revision: NOT_OBSERVED claim_relationship: DIRECT required_for_release: NO required_inspection_method: logged-out remote review after an authorized transfer inspection_state: NOT_TESTED evidence: no upload, deployment, queue action, post, or publication occurred inventory_gate_state: CORRECT_WITHIN_RECORDED_SCOPE inventory_gate_evidence: all eight classes were considered; non-applicable sound and timed text have manifest-based reasons inventory_gate_notes: destination remains NOT_TESTED rather than inferred from local state D. FORWARD TRACE FROM THE OLD MEANING ------------------------------------- B-PATH-01 from_claim_or_surface_identity: old four-lane method revision METHOD-B04 copy_or_transformation: summarized in ARTICLE-B04 and CARD-B04 next_surface_id: superseded local members old_meaning_possible: YES inspection_state: SUPERSEDED evidence: historical synthetic revisions are excluded from MANIFEST-B06 next_path_or_terminal_surface: B-PATH-02 and B-PATH-03 B-PATH-02 from_claim_or_surface_identity: superseded ARTICLE-B04 copy_or_transformation: article, card, worksheet, discovery, and manifest rebuilt from METHOD-B06 next_surface_id: B-PICTURE-01; B-DISCOVERY-01; B-PACKAGE-01 old_meaning_possible: NO within inspected scope inspection_state: CORRECT_WITHIN_RECORDED_SCOPE evidence: exact current members consistently represent six lanes next_path_or_terminal_surface: verified corrected terminals B-PATH-03 from_claim_or_surface_identity: superseded ARTICLE-B04 summary copy_or_transformation: manually copied into prepared profile text before correction next_surface_id: B-PROMOTION-01 old_meaning_possible: YES inspection_state: OLD_CLAIM_PRESENT evidence: PROMOTION-B04 retains the four-lane claim next_path_or_terminal_surface: terminal held promotion surface forward_trace_state: OLD_CLAIM_PRESENT forward_trace_evidence: manually prepared copy preserves old semantic identity forward_trace_notes: local package closure does not authorize stale promotion copy E. BACKWARD TRACE FROM FINAL CLAIM-BEARING MEMBERS -------------------------------------------------- ARTICLE-B06 lane list immediate_source_identity: METHOD-B06 ultimate_basis_revision: METHOD-B06 communicated_meaning: six separate lanes supports_corrected_meaning: YES old_meaning_could_survive: NO within inspected article lineage_state: CORRECT_WITHIN_RECORDED_SCOPE CARD-B06 six-column layout immediate_source_identity: METHOD-B06 ultimate_basis_revision: METHOD-B06 communicated_meaning: six separate lanes supports_corrected_meaning: YES old_meaning_could_survive: NO within inspected card lineage_state: CORRECT_WITHIN_RECORDED_SCOPE WORKSHEET-B06 review section immediate_source_identity: METHOD-B06 ultimate_basis_revision: METHOD-B06 communicated_meaning: six named decisions stay separate supports_corrected_meaning: YES old_meaning_could_survive: NO within inspected worksheet lineage_state: CORRECT_WITHIN_RECORDED_SCOPE PROMOTION-B04 compact summary immediate_source_identity: superseded ARTICLE-B04 ultimate_basis_revision: METHOD-B04 communicated_meaning: four lanes are complete supports_corrected_meaning: NO old_meaning_could_survive: YES lineage_state: OLD_CLAIM_PRESENT backward_trace_state: OLD_CLAIM_PRESENT backward_trace_evidence: prepared summary traces to superseded article revision backward_trace_notes: promotion copy is outside the deployable package but inside declared correction scope F. SEARCH, MEANING, AND PERCEPTUAL INSPECTION --------------------------------------------- exact_text_search: finding: old sentence absent from package, present in PROMOTION-B04 state: OLD_CLAIM_PRESENT numeric_and_unit_search: finding: numeral 4 appears only in unrelated checklist numbering inside package; semantic review clears those occurrences state: CORRECT_WITHIN_RECORDED_SCOPE limitation: raw numeric matches require context structural_inspection: finding: manifest admits only ARTICLE-B06, CARD-B06, and WORKSHEET-B06 state: CORRECT_WITHIN_RECORDED_SCOPE visual_review: finding: card renders six visible labeled columns without clipping state: CORRECT_WITHIN_RECORDED_SCOPE listening_review: finding: not applicable because manifest admits no sound state: CORRECT_WITHIN_RECORDED_SCOPE cross_surface_review: finding: package and discovery agree; prepared promotion contradicts them state: CONTRADICTORY lineage_review: finding: package members trace to METHOD-B06; promotion traces to METHOD-B04 state: OLD_CLAIM_PRESENT metadata_review: finding: title, excerpt, feed summary, preview description, and alt text preserve six-lane scope state: CORRECT_WITHIN_RECORDED_SCOPE inspection_matrix_state: CONTRADICTORY inspection_matrix_evidence: combined search and lineage isolate stale prepared copy without mislabeling the local package G. EXACT DELIVERY AND PACKAGE REVIEW ------------------------------------ delivery_package_revision: PACKAGE-B06 manifest_revision: MANIFEST-B06 package_members_observed: ARTICLE-B06; CARD-B06; WORKSHEET-B06 package_matches_manifest: YES complete_picture_review: YES complete_sound_playback: NOT_APPLICABLE_WITH_REASON — no sound member captions_and_timed_text_reviewed: NOT_APPLICABLE_WITH_REASON — no timed-text member title_description_excerpt_reviewed: YES thumbnail_preview_and_alt_text_reviewed: YES feed_and_promotion_copy_reviewed: YES container_and_file_metadata_reviewed: YES superseded_outputs_excluded: YES from package; NO from prepared-copy set delivery_finding: exact local package consistently represents six lanes delivery_state: CORRECT_WITHIN_RECORDED_SCOPE promotion_finding: exact prepared summary retains four-lane claim promotion_state: OLD_CLAIM_PRESENT required_repair: regenerate promotion copy from ARTICLE-B06, assign a new identity, and recheck lifecycle language before any use delivery_gate_state: CORRECT_WITHIN_RECORDED_SCOPE release_adjacent_copy_gate_state: OLD_CLAIM_PRESENT H. CHANGE AND INVALIDATION MAP ------------------------------ change_id: FICTIONAL-CHANGE-B07 changed_identity: proposed PROMOTION-B04 to PROMOTION-B06 change_summary: replace stale four-lane summary with scoped six-lane description dependent_claims_or_conclusions: lane count, completeness language, and prepared link metadata historical_evidence_marked: SUPERSEDED reopened_promotion_surfaces: full and compact prepared copy reopened_discovery_surfaces: only if shared source text changes reopened_package_surfaces: none if ARTICLE-B06, CARD-B06, WORKSHEET-B06, and MANIFEST-B06 remain byte-identical reopened_destination_surfaces: none; no destination exists recheck_state: NOT_TESTED evidence: repair is specified but not performed in this fictional record I. DESTINATION BOUNDARY ----------------------- local_package_state: CORRECT_WITHIN_RECORDED_SCOPE prepared_promotion_state: OLD_CLAIM_PRESENT upload_state: NOT_UPLOADED queue_state: NOT_QUEUED publication_state: NOT_PUBLIC destination_state: NOT_TESTED remote_cache_state: NOT_TESTED feed_at_destination_state: NOT_TESTED public_preview_state: NOT_TESTED boundary_statement: A passing local package does not prove transfer, provider processing, cache refresh, index coverage, logged-out availability, or publication. A stale local promotion packet is held rather than treated as public misinformation because it was not posted, queued, sent, or used for outreach. J. TERMINAL DECISION -------------------- selected_decision: HOLD_OLD_CLAIM_PRESENT correction_id: FICTIONAL-CORR-B01 basis_state: CORRECT_WITHIN_RECORDED_SCOPE local_package_state: CORRECT_WITHIN_RECORDED_SCOPE propagation_state: OLD_CLAIM_PRESENT cross_surface_state: CONTRADICTORY final_review_state: FAIL_FOR_DECLARED_CORRECTION_SCOPE remaining_unknowns: proposed promotion revision is unbuilt; all destination states are NOT_TESTED bounded_statement: The exact fictional local package consistently communicates the supported six-lane method, but prepared first-party copy still says four and must not be used. publication_state: NOT_PUBLIC promotion_state: NOT_POSTED_OR_QUEUED ======================================================================== CROSS-EXAMPLE TEST RESULTS ======================================================================== [PASS] Exact old wording remains: Example 2 search finds it in prepared copy. [PASS] Paraphrased old meaning remains: Example 1 listening finds spoken “five.” [PASS] Numeric variant is contextualized: Example 2 does not mistake checklist item 4 for the old claim. [PASS] Correct agreement cannot repair basis: both examples keep basis as a separate decision. [PASS] Clean editable state cannot approve stale delivery: Example 1 exact mix fails. [PASS] Correct captions cannot outweigh contradictory sound: Example 1 remains held. [PASS] Non-applicable surfaces require reasons: Example 2 binds sound and timed-text absence to the manifest. [PASS] Stale promotion copy blocks its own use: Example 2 remains not posted or queued. [PASS] Backward lineage catches stale inputs: both failures trace to superseded revisions. [PASS] Proposed repairs do not inherit passes: both change maps remain NOT_TESTED. [PASS] Dependent conclusions stay scoped: neither example creates benchmark or completeness claims. [PASS] Unobserved destinations remain NOT_TESTED: neither local fixture claims publication or refresh. Final method boundary --------------------- These records demonstrate only that the worksheet can represent two fictional failure paths without collapsing basis, propagation, cross-surface, package, promotion, and destination states. They contain original text and synthetic identifiers only. They are not evidence of a real correction, upload, publication, audience response, accessibility result, legal conclusion, or platform outcome.