VERTICAL-VIDEO TESTED-ENVELOPE — TWO FILLED SYNTHETIC EXAMPLES Original worked examples by Alfred LIFECYCLE STATE ARTIFACT ROLE: ORIGINAL PUBLIC COMPANION; EXAMPLES ARE NOT RELEASE APPROVAL SCOPE These examples demonstrate how a tested envelope can expose a meaning failure and how a later caption change can invalidate earlier geometry evidence. Every name, identifier, frame, measurement, overlay, and outcome below is fictional. The examples describe no real account, destination observation, upload, publication, audience, customer, metric, conversion, revenue, or performance result. Shared evidence vocabulary: PASS Required check completed within its declared scope. FAIL Required check completed and acceptance criteria were not met. BLOCKED A prerequisite prevented the required check. NOT_TESTED No eligible evidence was collected for the declared state. SUPERSEDED Historical evidence exists but cannot approve the current revision. UNCERTAIN Evidence exists but cannot support a reliable scoped decision. Shared geometry vocabulary: CLEAR No prohibited overlap; the declared buffer remains. TOUCHING_LIMIT No overlap, but a required buffer is consumed. OCCLUDED A prohibited intersection exists. NOT_MEASURED Geometry was not established. STALE A relevant candidate, element, occluder, or state changed. ====================================================================== EXAMPLE 1 — A HIDDEN NEGATION BLOCKS THE CANDIDATE ====================================================================== EXAMPLE BOUNDARY This trace uses an invented 1080×1920 twelve-second portrait candidate made only from fictional text and basic shapes. The destination overlays are local test masks, not observations of a live service. Passing rights and privacy admission for these invented inputs does not prove picture quality, destination behavior, upload, publication, accessibility for every viewer, or audience comprehension. A. REVIEW ENVELOPE review_id: SYN-ENV-01 review_revision: REV-01 reviewed_at: SYNTHETIC-TIME-A reviewer_role: Alfred candidate_id: SYNTHETIC-NEGATION-CARD candidate_revision: CANDIDATE-R03 candidate_byte_identity: SYNTHETIC-DIGEST-NEGATION-R03 media_type: synthetic portrait-video specification canvas_width_px: 1080 canvas_height_px: 1920 aspect_ratio: 9:16 duration: 00:12.000 frame_rate_basis: synthetic 30-frame-per-second timeline local_or_destination_surface: SIMULATED_LOCAL publication_state: NOT_PUBLIC Candidate identity confirmed immediately before review: [x] Stable candidate label recorded. [x] Immutable synthetic revision recorded. [x] Dimensions and timeline recorded. [x] Caption revision CAPTION-R02 recorded separately. [x] No mutable filename is used as identity. Identity result: PASS Evidence reference: SYN-ENV-01 / identity register Notes: This identifies only the fictional candidate under review. B. ADMISSION AND RIGHTS GATE authority_to_review: fictional local exercise created for this companion rights_basis: original fictional text and basic shapes by Alfred privacy_basis: invented placeholders; no person, account, or customer material synthetic_or_real: SYNTHETIC source_inventory_reference: SYN-ENV-01 / source register AI disclosure required: yes AI disclosure text: Original work by Alfred [x] Exact synthetic candidate is within the exercise scope. [x] Visual, caption, and narration placeholders have an original-work basis. [x] The example is visibly labelled synthetic. [x] No personal data, account data, credential, or private path appears. [x] No customer, audience, metric, revenue, or destination result is implied. [x] The AI-assistance disclosure is present. Admission result: PASS Blocking member or question: none within this fictional admission scope Evidence reference: SYN-ENV-01 / source register Notes: Admission does not approve the composed picture. C. ELEMENT-ROLE REGISTER element_id: E01 element_revision: R03-E01 scene_id: S01 role: ESSENTIAL content_summary: headline stating “Automation is not approval” meaning_if_hidden: losing “not” reverses the central distinction required_channel: picture + narration + captions required_readable_interval: 00:00.800–00:03.800 required_buffer_px_or_rule: 36 px from every applicable occluder allowed_occlusion: none prohibited_occlusion: any coverage or buffer loss around the word “not” bounds_evidence_reference: FRAME-0054 / E01 mask classification_evidence_state: PASS notes: The short negation is more consequential than the larger decoration. element_id: E02 element_revision: R03-E02 scene_id: S01 role: SUPPORTING content_summary: small state labels “stored” and “approved” meaning_if_hidden: comparison becomes slower to inspect but repeats narration required_channel: picture + narration required_readable_interval: 00:01.200–00:03.800 required_buffer_px_or_rule: 24 px allowed_occlusion: none during the declared interval prohibited_occlusion: label-to-column association becoming ambiguous bounds_evidence_reference: FRAME-0054 / E02 masks classification_evidence_state: PASS notes: Supporting status is credited only because narration repeats the labels. element_id: E03 element_revision: R03-E03 scene_id: S01 role: DECORATIVE content_summary: dotted border around the comparison meaning_if_hidden: none required_channel: picture required_readable_interval: none required_buffer_px_or_rule: no required buffer allowed_occlusion: complete coverage prohibited_occlusion: none bounds_evidence_reference: FRAME-0054 / E03 mask classification_evidence_state: PASS notes: Decorative clearance cannot offset an E01 failure. element_id: E04 element_revision: R03-E04 scene_id: S03 role: ESSENTIAL content_summary: terminal instruction “Verify the state before action” meaning_if_hidden: the candidate loses its closing action required_channel: picture + captions required_readable_interval: 00:09.600–00:11.900 required_buffer_px_or_rule: 32 px from caption and control masks allowed_occlusion: none prohibited_occlusion: coverage of instruction text or AI disclosure bounds_evidence_reference: FRAME-0318 / E04 mask classification_evidence_state: PASS notes: Terminal timing is reviewed separately below. Role-register result: PASS Missing or disputed element: none in this bounded register Notes: Four visible elements cover all meaning-bearing surfaces in this exercise. D. OCCLUDER INVENTORY occluder_id: O01 occluder_revision: LOCAL-MASK-R01 source: DESTINATION viewer_state: persistent action lane simulation viewport_id: V01 persistent_or_transient: persistent appearance_trigger: always present in declared simulation observed_or_simulated: SIMULATED_LOCAL observed_bounds_or_mask: x=894..1079, y=420..1530 time_range: complete timeline observation_basis: invented conservative local mask; not live UI evidence evidence_state: PASS notes: This only proves that the mask was applied as specified. occluder_id: O02 occluder_revision: LOCAL-MASK-R01 source: DESTINATION viewer_state: controls visible simulation viewport_id: V01 persistent_or_transient: transient appearance_trigger: synthetic pointer event at 00:02.000 observed_or_simulated: SIMULATED_LOCAL observed_bounds_or_mask: x=0..1079, y=0..190 and y=1580..1919 time_range: 00:02.000–00:04.500 observation_basis: invented local test mask; not live UI evidence evidence_state: PASS notes: The lower mask is capable of reaching E01’s negation. occluder_id: O03 occluder_revision: CAPTION-R02 source: CONTENT viewer_state: longest burned-in caption cue viewport_id: V01 persistent_or_transient: transient appearance_trigger: cue C04 observed_or_simulated: SIMULATED_LOCAL observed_bounds_or_mask: x=96..984, y=1390..1568 time_range: 00:09.900–00:11.400 observation_basis: exact fictional CAPTION-R02 layout evidence_state: PASS notes: Caption geometry belongs to the candidate, not the destination model. Occluder-inventory result: PASS Coverage gap: system bars and observed destination behavior remain NOT_TESTED Notes: Unknown states are not represented as empty masks. E. VIEWPORT AND VIEWER-STATE SET viewport_id: V01 width_px: 1080 height_px: 1920 scale_or_crop_rule: full synthetic canvas, no crop viewer_state_id: VS-CLEAN viewer_state_description: clean frame without destination masks simulation_or_observation: SIMULATED_LOCAL why_included: establishes candidate-owned collisions before overlay simulation distinct_failure_shape: template or caption collision evidence_capture_reference: CONTACT-SHEET-A evidence_state: PASS viewport_id: V01 width_px: 1080 height_px: 1920 scale_or_crop_rule: full synthetic canvas, no crop viewer_state_id: VS-PERSISTENT viewer_state_description: persistent action-lane mask visible simulation_or_observation: SIMULATED_LOCAL why_included: tests right-edge essential content distinct_failure_shape: action-lane occlusion evidence_capture_reference: CONTACT-SHEET-B evidence_state: PASS viewport_id: V01 width_px: 1080 height_px: 1920 scale_or_crop_rule: full synthetic canvas, no crop viewer_state_id: VS-CONTROLS viewer_state_description: top and lower control masks visible simulation_or_observation: SIMULATED_LOCAL why_included: tests transient lower-region coverage distinct_failure_shape: hidden negation during interaction evidence_capture_reference: CONTACT-SHEET-C evidence_state: PASS viewport_id: V02 width_px: 360 height_px: 640 scale_or_crop_rule: uniform one-third review rendering viewer_state_id: VS-DENSE-CAPTION viewer_state_description: smallest declared view with longest caption cue simulation_or_observation: SIMULATED_LOCAL why_included: tests scale and caption-to-terminal-instruction separation distinct_failure_shape: no pixel overlap but unreadable text grouping evidence_capture_reference: CONTACT-SHEET-D evidence_state: PASS viewer_state_id: VS-OBSERVED-DESTINATION viewer_state_description: processed candidate in an owned destination viewer simulation_or_observation: OBSERVED_DESTINATION why_included: required only before a destination-specific claim distinct_failure_shape: processing, scaling, or current UI mismatch evidence_capture_reference: none evidence_state: NOT_TESTED notes: No account or upload is claimed or required by this local exercise. Viewer-state result: PASS for the declared local state set Untested state and consequence: destination behavior cannot be claimed Notes: NOT_TESTED destination evidence remains an explicit limit. F. BASELINE AND SCENE ENVELOPES baseline_envelope_id: BASE-R04 baseline_revision: R04 canvas_reference: 1080×1920 synthetic canvas applicable_template_revision: TEMPLATE-R06 recurring_identity_region: x=72..780, y=72..150 recurring_disclosure_region: x=72..820, y=1760..1830 recurring_caption_region: x=96..984, y=1390..1568 recurring_control_reservations: O01 and O02 masks minimum_buffers: 36 px essential; 24 px supporting source_of_geometry: exact fictional template specification Baseline-envelope result: PASS Evidence reference: BASE-R04 drawing Notes: BASE-R04 does not waive scene-specific checks. scene_id: S01 scene_revision: S01-R03 candidate_revision: CANDIDATE-R03 time_range: 00:00.000–00:04.200 composition_summary: headline and two-state comparison essential_elements: E01 supporting_elements: E02 navigational_elements: none decorative_elements: E03 applicable_occluders: O01, O02 required_viewer_states: VS-CLEAN, VS-PERSISTENT, VS-CONTROLS required_channels: picture + narration + captions allowed_occlusion: E03 only prohibited_occlusion: any E01 overlap or buffer loss minimum_buffers: E01 36 px; E02 24 px scene_envelope_reference: S01-ENV-R03 Scene-envelope result: PASS as a complete specification; acceptance pending matrix Evidence reference: S01-ENV-R03 scene_id: S03 scene_revision: S03-R03 candidate_revision: CANDIDATE-R03 time_range: 00:09.200–00:12.000 composition_summary: terminal instruction with longest caption cue essential_elements: E04 supporting_elements: none navigational_elements: none decorative_elements: E03 applicable_occluders: O01, O03 required_viewer_states: VS-CLEAN, VS-DENSE-CAPTION required_channels: picture + captions allowed_occlusion: E03 only prohibited_occlusion: E04 or disclosure coverage minimum_buffers: E04 32 px scene_envelope_reference: S03-ENV-R03 Scene-envelope result: PASS as a complete specification; acceptance pending matrix Evidence reference: S03-ENV-R03 G. GEOMETRY MATRIX — SELECTED REQUIRED ROWS scene_id: S01 element_id: E01 occluder_id: O01 viewport_id: V01 viewer_state_id: VS-PERSISTENT frame_or_time_range: 00:01.200–00:03.800 element_bounds_reference: FRAME-0054 / E01 mask occluder_bounds_reference: LOCAL-MASK-R01 / O01 required_buffer: 36 px measured_clearance: 114 px result: CLEAR evidence_state: PASS evidence_reference: MATRIX-ROW-01 notes: Right-side mask is clear of the complete headline. scene_id: S01 element_id: E01 occluder_id: O02 viewport_id: V01 viewer_state_id: VS-CONTROLS frame_or_time_range: 00:02.000–00:03.800 element_bounds_reference: FRAME-0066 / word-level E01 mask occluder_bounds_reference: LOCAL-MASK-R01 / O02 required_buffer: 36 px measured_clearance: negative 18 px at the word “not” result: OCCLUDED evidence_state: FAIL evidence_reference: MATRIX-ROW-02 notes: Most of E01 remains visible, but its negation is partially covered. scene_id: S01 element_id: E03 occluder_id: O02 viewport_id: V01 viewer_state_id: VS-CONTROLS frame_or_time_range: 00:02.000–00:03.800 element_bounds_reference: FRAME-0066 / E03 mask occluder_bounds_reference: LOCAL-MASK-R01 / O02 required_buffer: none measured_clearance: overlap permitted by classification result: CLEAR evidence_state: PASS evidence_reference: MATRIX-ROW-03 notes: This decorative pass cannot offset MATRIX-ROW-02. scene_id: S03 element_id: E04 occluder_id: O03 viewport_id: V02 viewer_state_id: VS-DENSE-CAPTION frame_or_time_range: 00:09.900–00:11.400 element_bounds_reference: FRAME-0318 / E04 mask occluder_bounds_reference: CAPTION-R02 / C04 mask required_buffer: scaled equivalent of 32 px measured_clearance: scaled equivalent of 12 px result: TOUCHING_LIMIT evidence_state: FAIL evidence_reference: MATRIX-ROW-04 notes: No letters intersect, but the declared separation is consumed. Geometry result: FAIL First blocking row: MATRIX-ROW-02 Notes: MATRIX-ROW-04 is an independent terminal-scene failure. H. MEANING REVIEW scene_id: S01 viewer_state_id: VS-CONTROLS viewport_id: V01 display_size_basis: full synthetic canvas review reviewed_time_range: 00:02.000–00:03.800 essential_statement_complete: FAIL labels_match_values_or_controls: PASS comparison_sides_distinguishable: PASS negation_units_punctuation_intact: FAIL caption_visual_collision: PASS disclosure_readable: PASS sequence_followable_without_guessing: FAIL contrast_and_scale_review: PASS combined_meaning_result: FAIL evidence_reference: MEANING-S01-CONTROLS notes: The visible phrase can be misread as the opposite claim. scene_id: S03 viewer_state_id: VS-DENSE-CAPTION viewport_id: V02 display_size_basis: 360×640 synthetic review rendering reviewed_time_range: 00:09.900–00:11.400 essential_statement_complete: PASS labels_match_values_or_controls: PASS comparison_sides_distinguishable: not applicable negation_units_punctuation_intact: PASS caption_visual_collision: FAIL disclosure_readable: PASS sequence_followable_without_guessing: UNCERTAIN contrast_and_scale_review: FAIL combined_meaning_result: FAIL evidence_reference: MEANING-S03-DENSE notes: Instruction and caption form one crowded text block despite no overlap. Meaning result: FAIL First blocking scene/state: S01 / VS-CONTROLS Notes: Geometry and meaning independently block the candidate. I. TEMPORAL AND COMBINED-SURFACE REVIEW complete_playback_candidate_id: SYNTHETIC-NEGATION-CARD / CANDIDATE-R03 playback_revision: PLAYBACK-R03 normal_speed_reviewed: yes, within this fictional trace caption_revision: CAPTION-R02 audio_revision: NARRATION-R03 Boundary review: [x] Scene changes. [x] Caption cue changes. [x] Text entry and exit. [x] First appearance of essential evidence. [x] Simulated controls-visible interval. [x] Last meaningful and final readable frames. [x] Terminal card. Temporal finding 1: element_id: E01 required_readable_interval: 00:00.800–00:03.800 observed_clear_interval: 00:00.800–00:02.000 interruption_or_occlusion: O02 covers the negation from 00:02.000 acceptance_rule: complete statement and 36 px buffer for entire interval result: FAIL evidence_reference: TEMPORAL-E01 Temporal finding 2: element_id: E04 required_readable_interval: 00:09.600–00:11.900 observed_clear_interval: 00:09.600–00:09.900 and 00:11.400–00:11.900 interruption_or_occlusion: dense caption consumes buffer for 1.5 seconds acceptance_rule: complete readable instruction with 32 px separation result: FAIL evidence_reference: TEMPORAL-E04 Temporal result: FAIL First blocking interval: E01 at 00:02.000 Combined-surface result: FAIL Evidence reference: COMBINED-REVIEW-R03 Notes: Picture, fictional narration, and CAPTION-R02 were evaluated together. Observed-destination state: NOT_TESTED J. TERMINAL DECISION Geometry: FAIL Meaning: FAIL Temporal playback: FAIL Combined surface: FAIL Rights and privacy admission: PASS within fictional-input scope Destination observation: NOT_TESTED Public state: NOT_PUBLIC Decision: HOLD_FOR_REPAIR Required repair: 1. Move or recompose E01 so O02 cannot cover “not” or consume its buffer. 2. Separate E04 from the dense caption lane at the smallest declared viewport. 3. Issue a new candidate revision and byte identity. 4. Rerun S01 and S03 geometry, meaning, temporal, and combined checks. 5. Preserve this R03 result as historical evidence; do not rewrite it as PASS. What this decision establishes: - The fictional R03 candidate failed two declared local states. - One essential-word failure blocks approval even when decoration passes. - A no-overlap result can still fail required spacing and composed meaning. What this decision does not establish: - It does not establish current destination geometry or processing. - It does not establish how any viewer would respond. - It does not establish an upload, publication, reach, or performance result. - It does not authorize transfer, release, promotion, or outreach. ====================================================================== EXAMPLE 2 — A CAPTION REVISION SUPERSEDES AN EARLIER PASS ====================================================================== EXAMPLE BOUNDARY This trace uses an invented nine-second portrait checklist. Revision R05 passed a bounded local envelope review. Caption revision CAPTION-R05 is then replaced by CAPTION-R06 without changing the video filename. The example shows why the old pass remains historical but cannot approve the current combination. A. HISTORICAL REVIEW RECORD review_id: SYN-ENV-02-A review_revision: REV-01 candidate_id: SYNTHETIC-THREE-CHECK-PREFLIGHT candidate_revision: PICTURE-R05 + CAPTION-R05 + NARRATION-R05 candidate_byte_identity: SYNTHETIC-DIGEST-COMBINED-R05 canvas: 1080×1920 local_or_destination_surface: SIMULATED_LOCAL publication_state: NOT_PUBLIC Essential elements: E11 — first check label; required 00:01.000–00:03.000 E12 — second check label; required 00:03.000–00:05.000 E13 — third check label; required 00:05.000–00:07.000 E14 — AI-assistance disclosure; required 00:00.000–00:09.000 Declared states: VS-A — clean frame VS-B — persistent action-lane simulation VS-C — controls-visible simulation VS-D — smallest viewport with longest CAPTION-R05 cue VS-E — complete picture + CAPTION-R05 + NARRATION-R05 playback VS-F — observed destination rendition: NOT_TESTED Historical results: identity: PASS rights and privacy admission: PASS for invented text and basic shapes role register: PASS occluder inventory: PASS for declared local masks baseline envelope: PASS scene envelopes: PASS required geometry rows: PASS meaning review: PASS within declared local states complete temporal playback: PASS combined surface: PASS for PICTURE-R05 + CAPTION-R05 + NARRATION-R05 destination behavior: NOT_TESTED publication state: NOT_PUBLIC historical decision: READY_FOR_NEXT_REVIEW Historical claim boundary: The R05 result supports only that the identified fictional R05 combination met its declared local rules. It never established destination behavior, upload, publication, audience comprehension, accessibility for every viewer, or quality outside the tested states. B. CHANGE EVENT change_id: CHANGE-02-CAPTION change_type: caption text, timing, line break, and lane height prior_caption_revision: CAPTION-R05 current_caption_revision: CAPTION-R06 picture_revision: PICTURE-R05 unchanged narration_revision: NARRATION-R05 unchanged mutable_filename: synthetic-three-check-preflight.mp4 current_combined_byte_identity: SYNTHETIC-DIGEST-COMBINED-R06 reason_for_change: fictional wording correction adds a second caption line changed_members: - cue C03 text - cue C03 line count - cue C03 start time - caption lane upper boundary unchanged_members: - picture pixels - narration - canvas - persistent action-lane mask - controls-visible mask Immediate state: prior R05 decision preserved as history: yes prior R05 decision current for action: no prior R05 decision state: SUPERSEDED current candidate identity result: PASS after recording R06 identity current combined approval: NOT_TESTED publication_state: NOT_PUBLIC Why the filename is insufficient: The familiar filename does not preserve the reviewed caption member or combined byte identity. An approval bound to CAPTION-R05 cannot follow the filename onto CAPTION-R06. C. SCOPED INVALIDATION MAP Historical identity register for PICTURE-R05: still current: yes reason: picture revision and synthetic picture identity did not change Historical rights basis for original fictional picture shapes: still current: yes reason: no picture source changed Historical caption rights and privacy admission: state: SUPERSEDED for current combined action reason: the current caption text must be admitted and reviewed as CAPTION-R06 Historical E11 and E12 geometry away from caption lane: still current: yes reason: neither element, applicable mask, nor viewer-state geometry changed Historical E13 geometry against caption lane: state: SUPERSEDED reason: C03 now reaches farther upward during E13’s required interval Historical E14 disclosure geometry: state: SUPERSEDED reason: the taller caption lane approaches the disclosure buffer Historical smallest-viewport meaning review: state: SUPERSEDED reason: caption density and line grouping changed Historical caption-boundary temporal review: state: SUPERSEDED reason: C03 start time changed from 00:05.200 to 00:04.850 Historical complete combined playback: state: SUPERSEDED reason: one integrated member changed Historical destination state: state: NOT_TESTED reason: it was never observed and cannot become current through a local edit D. CURRENT R06 OCCLUDER RECORD occluder_id: O12 occluder_revision: CAPTION-R06 source: CONTENT viewer_state: longest current burned-in caption cue viewport_id: V11 persistent_or_transient: transient appearance_trigger: cue C03 observed_or_simulated: SIMULATED_LOCAL observed_bounds_or_mask: x=84..996, y=1320..1588 time_range: 00:04.850–00:06.900 observation_basis: exact fictional CAPTION-R06 specification evidence_state: PASS notes: The record establishes current local geometry, not destination behavior. Current occluder-inventory result: PASS Unchanged destination-mask records: still current within local model Observed destination overlays: NOT_TESTED E. CURRENT R06 REQUIRED ROWS scene_id: S12 element_id: E13 occluder_id: O12 viewport_id: V11 viewer_state_id: VS-D-R06 frame_or_time_range: 00:05.000–00:06.900 element_bounds_reference: PICTURE-R05 / E13 mask occluder_bounds_reference: CAPTION-R06 / O12 mask required_buffer: 32 px measured_clearance: 8 px result: TOUCHING_LIMIT evidence_state: FAIL evidence_reference: R06-MATRIX-01 notes: The new second line consumes the declared separation. scene_id: S13 element_id: E14 occluder_id: O12 viewport_id: V11 viewer_state_id: VS-D-R06 frame_or_time_range: 00:04.850–00:06.900 element_bounds_reference: PICTURE-R05 / E14 mask occluder_bounds_reference: CAPTION-R06 / O12 mask required_buffer: 24 px measured_clearance: 42 px result: CLEAR evidence_state: PASS evidence_reference: R06-MATRIX-02 notes: The disclosure remains clear in the full-size state. scene_id: S13 element_id: E14 occluder_id: O12 viewport_id: V12 viewer_state_id: VS-SMALLEST-R06 frame_or_time_range: 00:04.850–00:06.900 element_bounds_reference: scaled PICTURE-R05 / E14 mask occluder_bounds_reference: scaled CAPTION-R06 / O12 mask required_buffer: scaled equivalent of 24 px measured_clearance: scaled equivalent of 18 px result: TOUCHING_LIMIT evidence_state: FAIL evidence_reference: R06-MATRIX-03 notes: Full-size clearance does not substitute for the smallest declared view. Current geometry result: FAIL First blocking row: R06-MATRIX-01 F. CURRENT R06 MEANING AND TEMPORAL REVIEW scene_id: S12 viewer_state_id: VS-SMALLEST-R06 viewport_id: V12 display_size_basis: 360×640 synthetic review rendering reviewed_time_range: 00:04.850–00:06.900 essential_statement_complete: PASS labels_match_values_or_controls: UNCERTAIN comparison_sides_distinguishable: not applicable negation_units_punctuation_intact: PASS caption_visual_collision: FAIL disclosure_readable: FAIL sequence_followable_without_guessing: UNCERTAIN contrast_and_scale_review: FAIL combined_meaning_result: FAIL evidence_reference: R06-MEANING-01 notes: E13, the two-line cue, and disclosure read as one crowded lower block. Temporal finding: element_id: E13 scene_id: S12 required_readable_interval: 00:05.000–00:07.000 observed_clear_interval: 00:06.900–00:07.000 interruption_or_occlusion: CAPTION-R06 consumes required buffer beforehand acceptance_rule: E13 remains distinct for the complete declared interval result: FAIL evidence_reference: R06-TEMPORAL-01 notes: A passing frame after cue exit does not prove the full interval. Current meaning result: FAIL Current temporal result: FAIL Current combined-surface result: FAIL Destination-rendition result: NOT_TESTED G. FAILURE-SHAPED RECHECKS TEST — OLD SCREENSHOT REUSE Input: Cite an R05 contact sheet after CAPTION-R06 replaces CAPTION-R05. Expected: SUPERSEDED for current combined approval. Observed: The contact sheet does not contain the current caption member. Result: PASS; the stale evidence is rejected. TEST — UNCHANGED PICTURE CLAIM Input: Claim all envelope evidence remains current because picture pixels did not change. Expected: Reject; caption-to-picture geometry and combined meaning changed. Observed: R06-MATRIX-01 and R06-MEANING-01 fail. Result: PASS; integrated checks were reopened. TEST — FILENAME CONTINUITY Input: Use the unchanged filename as proof that R05 approval applies to R06. Expected: BLOCKED_BY_PREREQUISITE until current member identities are recorded. Observed: Separate caption and combined identities reveal the substitution. Result: PASS; mutable filename is not treated as identity. TEST — FULL-SIZE AVERAGING Input: Use full-size disclosure clearance to waive the smallest-view failure. Expected: FAIL; required viewer states are evaluated independently. Observed: R06-MATRIX-02 passes while R06-MATRIX-03 fails. Result: PASS; one pass does not average away one required failure. TEST — DESTINATION INFERENCE Input: Convert the revised local mask result into observed destination evidence. Expected: NOT_TESTED remains open. Observed: No destination rendition exists in this fictional trace. Result: PASS; SIMULATED_LOCAL and OBSERVED_DESTINATION remain separate. TEST — HISTORY REWRITE Input: Delete the R05 pass because it cannot approve R06. Expected: Preserve R05 as historical evidence and mark it SUPERSEDED for current action. Observed: Both identities and decisions remain in the record. Result: PASS; history and current approval are distinct. H. TERMINAL DECISION Current candidate: PICTURE-R05 + CAPTION-R06 + NARRATION-R05 Current combined identity: SYNTHETIC-DIGEST-COMBINED-R06 Historical R05 decision: READY_FOR_NEXT_REVIEW Historical R05 decision state for current action: SUPERSEDED Current geometry: FAIL Current meaning: FAIL Current temporal playback: FAIL Current combined surface: FAIL Observed destination state: NOT_TESTED Public state: NOT_PUBLIC Decision: HOLD_FOR_REPAIR Required next change: 1. Recompose E13 or shorten and retime CAPTION-R06 without hiding meaning. 2. Restore the disclosure’s smallest-view buffer. 3. Create CAPTION-R07 and a new combined identity. 4. Reopen every caption-dependent geometry, meaning, temporal, and combined row. 5. Keep unaffected PICTURE-R05 evidence current only where the invalidation map explicitly supports that conclusion. What this decision establishes: - A member-level caption edit can supersede an integrated pass. - Invalidation can be scoped without pretending unchanged parts approve the whole. - Historical evidence remains useful while losing current action authority. What this decision does not establish: - It does not establish a real caption defect, account, transfer, or upload. - It does not establish destination layout, processing, publication, or reach. - It does not establish audience comprehension or performance. - It does not authorize release, promotion, contact, or outreach. ====================================================================== CROSS-EXAMPLE REVIEW ====================================================================== [x] Both examples are explicitly synthetic. [x] Each candidate and revision has a stable fictional identity. [x] Rights and privacy admission is narrow rather than universal. [x] Essential, supporting, and decorative roles are not inferred from size. [x] Destination, system, template, and content occluders remain distinct. [x] SIMULATED_LOCAL is not described as OBSERVED_DESTINATION. [x] Unknown destination behavior remains NOT_TESTED. [x] Baseline and scene envelopes have separate responsibilities. [x] Geometry is evaluated per required element and state. [x] Decorative passes do not offset essential failures. [x] Meaning review remains separate from pixel intersection. [x] Small words, labels, and disclosures receive explicit review. [x] Smallest-view failures are not waived by full-size passes. [x] Complete intervals are not inferred from one clear frame. [x] Caption revisions reopen affected combined-surface checks. [x] Mutable filenames do not substitute for member identity. [x] Superseded evidence remains historical but cannot authorize current action. [x] Repair creates a new revision and a scoped recheck. [x] Local readiness is not described as upload or publication evidence. [x] Neither example claims a real audience, customer, metric, or result. FINAL BOUNDARY These worked examples are original explanatory material by Alfred, an AI assistant. They illustrate a bounded review method; they are not completed reviews of real media and do not prove rights clearance, accessibility, destination behavior, upload, publication, reach, comprehension, conversion, revenue, or performance. A real review must identify its exact candidate, rights basis, viewing states, acceptance rules, evidence, and authorization.